Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal
Volume 14, Issue 4 , Pages 217-225 , November 2011

A systematic review of the impact of afterhours care models on emergency departments, ambulance and general practice services

  • Margaret M. Fry, PhD

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationCorresponding author. Tel.: +61 02 9514 4826; fax: +61 02 9514 4835.

Received 31 March 2011 ,Revised 16 September 2011 ,Accepted 20 September 2011.

References 

  1. Allen Booze, Hamilton . key drivers of demand in the Emergency Department. Sydney: NSW Health Department; 2007;
  2. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare . Australian hospital statistics 2009–2010. Canberra: AIHW; 2010;
  3. Leibowitz R, Day S, Dunt D. A systematic review of the effect of different models of after-hours primary medical care services on clinical outcome, medical workload, and patient and GP satisfaction. Family Practice. 2003;20:311–317
  4. Hurst K. British out-of-hours primary and community care: a review of the literature. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance Incorporating Leadership in Health Services. 2006;19:42–59
  5. Roberts E, Mays N. Can primary care and community-based models of emergency care substitute for the hospital accident and emergency (A&E) department?. Health Policy. 1998;44:191–214
  6. Salisbury C. The demand for out-of-hours care from GPs: a review. Family Practice. 2000;17:340–347
  7. Sakr M, Angus J, Perrin J, Nixon C, Nicholl J, Wardrope J. Care of minor injuries by emergency nurse practitioners or junior doctors: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 1999;354:1321–1326
  8. Paxton F, Heaney D. Minor injuries units: evaluating patients’ perceptions. Nursing Standard. 1997;12:45–47
  9. Heaney D, Paxton F. Evaluation of a nurse-led minor injuries unit. Nursing Standard. 1997;12:35–38
  10. Moser MS, Abu-Laban RB, van Beek CA. Attitude of emergency department patients with minor problems to being treated by a nurse practitioner. CJEM: The Journal of the Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians. 2004;6:246–252
  11. Byrne C, Bell B, Roberts J, Browne GB, Jamieson E, Vandervlist I. Primary care in Ontario, Canada: implications for the complementary role of the nurse practitioner. Clinical Excellence for Nurse Practitioners. 1997;1:15–21
  12. Hutchinson B. The place of walk in clinics in health care systems. British Medical Journal. 2000;321:909–910
  13. Wilson A, Zwart E, Everett I, Kernick J. The clinical effectiveness of nurse practitioners’ management of minor injuries in an adult emergency department: a systematic review. International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare. 2009;7:3–14
  14. Shum C, Humphreys A, Wheeler D, Cochrane MA, Skoda S, Clement S. Nurse management of patients with minor illnesses in general practice: multicentre, randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal. 2000;320:1038–1043
  15. Beales J, Baker B. Minor injuries unit: expanding the scope of accident and emergency provision. Accident & Emergency Nursing. 1995;3:65–67
  16. Beales J. Management. Innovation in accident and emergency management: establishing a nurse practitioner-run minor injuries/primary care unit. Accident & Emergency Nursing. 1997;5:71–75
  17. Rizos J, Anglin P, Grava-Gubins I, Lazar C. Walk-in clinics: implications for family practice. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 1990;143:740–745
  18. Salisbury C, Munro J. Walk-in centres in primary care: a review of the international literature. British Journal of General Practice. 2003;53:53–59
  19. Hellstern R. The impact of ambulatory care centers on emergency medicine. Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America. 1987;5:103–117
  20. Szafran O, Bell NR. Use of walk-in clinics by rural and urban patients. Canadian Family Physician. 2000;46:114–119
  21. Rudd K. Walk in Centre at the Canberra Hospital. Media Statement. 2009;
  22. Chalder M, Montgomery A, Hollinghurst S, Cooke M, Munro J, Lattimer V, et al. Comparing care at walk-in centres and at accident and emergency departments: an exploration of patient choice, preference and satisfaction. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2007;24:260–264
  23. Salisbury C, Chalder M, Scott TM, Pope C, Moore L. What is the role of walk-in centres in the NHS?. British Medical Journal. 2002;324:399–402
  24. Salisbury C, Chalder M, Scott T, Pope C, Moore L. What is the role of walk-in centres in the NHS?. British Medical Journal. 2002;324:399–402
  25. Maheswaran R, Pearson T, Munro J, Jiwa M, Campbell MJ, Nicholl J. Impact of NHS walk-in centres on primary care access times: ecological study. British Medical Journal. 2007;334:838
  26. Chalder M, Sharp D, Moore L, Salisbury C. Impact of NHS walk-in centres on the workload of other local healthcare providers: time series analysis. British Medical Journal. 2003;326:532
  27. Bunn F, Byrne G, Kendall S. Telephone consultation and triage: effects on health care use and patient satisfaction. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2009;
  28. Lattimer V, Smith H, Hungin P, Glasper A, George S. Future provision of out of hours primary medical care: a survey with two general practitioner research networks. British Medical Journal. 1996;312:352–356
  29. Munro J, Sampson F, Nicholl J. The impact of NHS Direct on the demand for out-of-hours primary and emergency care. British Journal of General Practice. 2005;55:790–792
  30. Byrne G, Morgan J, Kendall S, Saberi D. A survey of NHS Direct callers’ use of health services and the interventions they received. Primary Health Care Research & Development. 2007;8:91–100
  31. Boardman J, Steele C. NHS Direct—a telephone helpline for England and Wales. Psychiatric Bulletin. 2002;26:42–44
  32. Hansen BL, Munck A. Out-of-hours service in Denmark: the effect of a structural change. British Journal of General Practice. 1998;48:1497–1499
  33. Christensen MB, Olesen F. Out of hours service in Denmark: evaluation five years after reform. British Medical Journal. 1998;316:1502–1505
  34. Giesen P, Ferwerda R, Tijssen R, Mokkink H, Drijver R, van den Bosch W, et al. Safety of telephone triage in general practitioner cooperatives: do triage nurses correctly estimate urgency?. Quality & Safety in Health Care. 2007;16:181–184
  35. Dunt D, Wilson R, Day S, Kelaher M, Gurrin L. Impact of telephone triage on emergency after hours GP Medicare usage: a time-series analysis. Australia and New Zealand Health Policy. 2007;4:21
  36. Eminovic N, Wyatt JC, Tarpey AM, Murray G, Ingrams GJ. First evaluation of the NHS direct online clinical enquiry service: a nurse-led web chat triage service for the public. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2004;6:e17
  37. Bunn F, Byrne G, Kendall S. Telephone consultation and triage: effects on health care use and patient satisfaction. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2008;
  38. Buesching DP, Jablonowski A, Vesta E, Dilts W, Runge C, Lund J, et al. Inappropriate emergency department visits. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 1985;14:672–676
  39. Darnell JC, Hiner SL, Neill PJ, Mamlin JJ, McDonald CJ, Hui SL, et al. After-hours telephone access to physicians with access to computerized medical records. Experience in an inner-city general medicine clinic. Medical Care. 1985;23:20–26
  40. Fatovich DM, Hughes G, McCarthy SM. Access block: it's all about available beds. Medical Journal of Australia. 2009;190:362–363
  41. Raftery J. Nurse telephone consultation for out-of-hours primary care can save money through reduced ER admissions, surgery attendance and GP home visits. Evidence-based Healthcare. 2000;4:61–61
  42. Lattimer V, George S, Thompson F, Thomas E, Mullee M, Turnbull J, et al. Safety and effectiveness of nurse telephone consultation in out of hours primary care: randomised controlled trial. The South Wiltshire Out of Hours Project (SWOOP) Group. British Medical Journal. 1998;317:1054–1059
  43. Lattimer V, Turnbull J, Burgess A, Surridge H, Gerard K, Lathlean J, et al. Effect of introduction of integrated out of hours care in England: observational study. British Medical Journal. 2005;331:81–84
  44. Pooley C, Briggs J, Gatrell T, Mansfield T, Cummings D, Deft J. Contacting your GP when the surgery is closed: issues of location and access. Health & Place. 2003;9:23–32
  45. Olesen F, Jolleys JV. Out of hours service: the Danish solution examined. British Medical Journal. 1994;309:1624–1626
  46. Vedsted P, Christensen MB. The effect of an out-of-hours reform on attendance at casualty wards. The Danish example. Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care. 2001;19:95–98
  47. Hanson RM, Exley BJ, Ngo P, Fitzpatrick MP, Petering EL, Matthews SJ, et al. Paediatric telephone triage and advice: the demand continues. Medical Journal of Australia. 2004;180:333–335
  48. Bolton P, Gannon S, Aro D. HealthConnect: a trial of an after-hours telephone triage service. Australian Health Review. 2002;25:95–103
  49. Western Australian Department of Health . HealthDirect 2nd Quarterly Report. WA Department of Health; 2008;
  50. Commonwealth Minister for Health and Ageing . Health direct Australia. Excerpt HSNET e-bulletin. 2008;
  51. Hallam L. Primary medical care outside normal working hours: review of published work. British Medical Journal. 1994;308:249–253
  52. Brogan C, Pickard D, Gray A, Fairman S, Hill A. The use of out of hours health services: a cross sectional survey. British Medical Journal. 1998;316:524–527
  53. Kravet S, Shore A, Miller R, Green G, Kolodner K, Wright S. Health care utilization and the proportion of primary care physicians. The American Journal of Medicine. 2008;121:142–148
  54. Scott A, Simoens S, Heaney D, O’Donnell CA, Thomson H, Moffat KJ, et al. What does GP out of hours care cost? An analysis of different models of out of hours care in Scotland. Scottish Medical Journal. 2004;49:61–66
  55. Grol R, Giesen P, van Uden C. After-hours care in the United Kingdom, Denmark, and the Netherlands: new models. Health Affairs. 2006;25:1733–1737
  56. van Uden CJT, Winkens RAG, Wesseling GJ, Crebolder HFJM, van Schayck CP. Use of out of hours services: a comparison between two organisations. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2003;20:184–187
  57. van Uden CJT, Crebolder HFJM. Does setting up out of hours primary care cooperatives outside a hospital reduce demand for emergency care?. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2004;21:722–723
  58. van Uden C, Nieman FM, Voss G, Wesseling G, Winkens R, Crebolder HM. General practitioners’ satisfaction with and attitudes to out-of-hours services. BMC Health Services Research. 2005;5:27
  59. Douglas K. New models of primary care—the evidence. Canberra: Australian National University; 2008;
  60. Sibthorpe B. Development of the first national performance indicators for Divisions of General Practice—research policy interface in action. Canberra: Australian Primary Health Care Research Institute; 2008;
  61. Jessopp L, Beck I, Hollins L, Shipman C, Reynolds M, Dale J. Changing the pattern out of hours: a survey of general practice cooperatives. British Medical Journal. 1997;314:199–200
  62. van Uden CJT, Giesen PHJ, Metsemakers JFM, Grol RPTM. Development of out-of-hours primary care by general practitioners (GPs) in The Netherlands: from small-call rotations to large-scale GP cooperatives. Family Medicine. 2006;38:565–569
  63. Salisbury C. Evaluation of a general practice out of hours cooperative: a questionnaire survey of general practitioners. British Medical Journal. 1997;314:1598–1599
  64. Scott A, Watson M, Ross S. Eliciting preferences of the community for out of hours care provided by general practitioners: a stated preference discrete choice experiment. Social Science & Medicine. 2003;56:803–814
  65. Giesen P, Willekens M, Mokkink H, Braspenning J, Van Den Bosch W, Grol R. Out-of-hours primary care: development of indicators for prescribing and referring. International Journal for Quality in Health Care. 2007;19:289–295
  66. van Uden CT, Ament AHA, Hobma SO, Zwietering P, Crebolder HM. Patient satisfaction with out-of-hours primary care in the Netherlands. BMC Health Services Research. 2005;5:6
  67. O‘Dowd TC, McNamara K, Kelly A, O‘Kelly F. Out-of-hours Co-Operatives: general practitioner satisfaction with governance and working arrangements. European Journal of General Practice. 2006;12:15–18
  68. Bolton P, Thompson L. The reasons for, and lessons learned from, the closure of the Canterbury GP After-Hours Service. Australian Health Review. 2001;24:66–73
  69. Buckley DJ, Curtis PW, McGirr JG, Buckley DJ, Curtis PW, McGirr JG. The effect of a general practice after-hours clinic on emergency department presentations: a regression time series analysis. Medical Journal of Australia. 2010;192:448–451
  70. Dunt D, Day S, Kelaher M, Montalto M. The impact of standalone call centres and GP cooperatives on access to after hours GP care: a before and after study adjusted for secular trend. Family Practice. 2006;23:453–460
  71. Naccarella L, Southern D, Furler J, Scott A, Prosser L, Young D. Siren Project; systems innovation and reviews of evidence of primary health care. Canberra, ACT: The Department of General Practice & Melbourne Institute of Applied Economics and Social Research, Australian Government, Department of Health and Ageing; 2006;
  72. KPMG . The National Health Workforce Strategic Framework. Canberra: National Health Workforce Taskforce; 2009;
  73. Comino E, Zwar N, Hermiz O. The Macarthur GP after-hours service: a model of after-hours care for Australia. Australian Health Review. 2007;31:223–230
  74. Kelaher M, Dunt D, Feldman P. Effects of financial disadvantage on use and non-use of afterhours care in Australia. Health Policy. 2006;79:16–23
  75. Mason S, Knowles E, Colwell B, Dixon S, Wardrope J, Gorringe R, et al. Effectiveness of paramedic practitioners in attending 999 calls from elderly people in the community: cluster randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal. 2007;335:919
  76. Snooks H, Kearsley N, Dale J, Halter M, Redhead J, Cheung WY. Towards primary care for non-serious 999 callers: results of a controlled study of “Treat and Refer” protocols for ambulance crews. Quality & Safety in Health Care. 2004;13:435–443
  77. Snooks H, Foster T, Nicholl J. Results of an evaluation of the effectiveness of triage and direct transportation to minor injuries units by ambulance crews. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2004;21:105–111
  78. Nicholl J. What direction of travel? Reconfiguring emergency and urgent care. Sheffield: Medical Care Research Unit; 2008;
  79. Sjonell G. Effect of establishing a primary health care centre on the utilization of primary health care and other out-patient care in a Swedish urban area. Family Practice. 1986;3:148–154
  80. Bury G, Hungerford P, Langton D, Plunkett P. A&E services in Ireland: the potential role of general practice in accident and emergency services. Irish Journal of Medical Science. 2000;169:245–247
  81. Ullman R, Block JA, Boatright NC, Stratmann WC. Impact of a primary care group practice on emergency room utilization at a community hospital. Medical Care. 1978;16:723–729
  82. Paneth N, Bell D, Stein RE. Emergency room utilization in the first 15 months of life: a randomized study. Pediatrics. 1979;63:486–490
  83. Ward P, Huddy J, Hargreaves S, Touquet R, Hurley J, Fothergill J. Primary care in London: an evaluation of general practitioners working in an inner city accident and emergency department. Journal of Accident & Emergency Medicine. 1996;13:11–15
  84. Dale J, Green J, Reid F, Glucksman E, Higgs R. Primary care in the accident and emergency department: II. Comparison of general practitioners and hospital doctors. British Medical Journal. 1995;311:427–430
  85. Murphy AW, Bury G, Plunkett PK, Gibney D, Smith M, Mullan E, et al. Randomised controlled trial of general practitioner versus usual medical care in an urban accident and emergency department: process, outcome, and comparative cost. British Medical Journal. 1996;312:1135–1142
  86. Bolton P, Mira M, Jones M. The impact of a general practice staffed casualty service on overall primary medical services. NSW Public Health Bulletin. 1998;12:296–298
  87. Sakr M, Kendall R, Angus J, Sanders A, Nicholl J, Wardrope J. Emergency nurse practitioners: a three part study in clinical and cost effectiveness. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2003;20:158–163
  88. Snooks H, Nicholl J. Sorting patients: the weakest link in the emergency care system. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2007;24:74
  89. Munro J, Nicoll J, O‘Cathain A, Knowles E. Impact of NHS Direct on demand for immediate care: observational study. BMJ. 2000;2000:150–153
  90. Salisbury C, Manku-Cott T, Moore L, Chalder M, Sharp D. Questionnaire survey of users of NHS walk-in centres: observational study. British Journal of General Practice. 2002;52:554–560
  91. Salisbury C, Hollinghurst S, Montgomery A, Cooke M, Munro J, Sharp D, et al. The impact of co-located NHS walk-in centres on emergency departments. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2007;24:265–269
  92. Olshaker J, Rathlev NK. Emergency department overcrowding and ambulance diversion: the impact and potential solutions of extended boarding of admitted patients in the emergency department. Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2006;30:351–356
  93. Richardson D, Kelly A-M, Kerr D. Prevalence of access block in Australia 2004–2008. Emergency Medicine Australasia. 2009;21:472–478
  94. Cameron P. Hospital overcrowding a threat to patient safety?. Medical Journal of Australia. 2006;184:203–204
  95. Fry M. Barriers and facilitators for successful after hours care model implementation: reducing emergency department utilisation. Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal. 2009;12:137–144

PII: S1574-6267(11)00122-4

doi: 10.1016/j.aenj.2011.09.001

Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal
Volume 14, Issue 4 , Pages 217-225 , November 2011

Article Tools

* Image Usage & Resolution